Baby's first Christmas: give the tradition, not the toy.
The baby will sleep through most of it. The best first Christmas gifts are the ones the family brings out every December after: a first Christmas book, a dated ornament, a keepsake with the baby's name on it. Everything below is chosen to still matter at Christmas number ten.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Our keepsake books are our own.
Start with the Christmas story itself
One book carries the whole reason for the season, and this retelling is the one from our research shelf we recommend for the earliest Christmases: gentle, beautifully illustrated, made for a lap and a quiet evening.
Beautiful retelling of the Christmas story with gentle illustrations. Perfect for family reading during Advent.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Want to preview the tone tonight, free? Read our gentle Birth of Jesus story or print the Birth of Jesus coloring page.
Keepsakes that come out every December
Four categories that turn into traditions. We link each to a search rather than one product, so you can pick the style that fits the family.
A dated first-Christmas ornament
The most-given first Christmas gift there is, for a reason: it comes out of the box every single December, with the year on it.
Find it on Amazon →A nativity board book
The Christmas story in ten sturdy pages. Look for thick pages and soft art; this one gets read (and gummed) all month.
Find it on Amazon →God Gave Us Christmas
Little Cub asks who invented Christmas. A nursery staple from the God Gave Us series, and a natural first-Christmas gift.
Find it on Amazon →Our full guide →A keepsake stocking or blanket
A stocking with the baby's name hangs on the mantel this year and every year after. The blanket version wraps the church photos.
Find it on Amazon →The keepsake no one else can give
Little Prayers is the personalized book we make ourselves: ten gentle bedtime prayers, each paired with a Bible verse, with the baby illustrated into every spread and their name on the cover. The dedication page holds the date, first Christmases included.
Build the baby's look in the customizer, write the dedication for their first Christmas, and we print the book on demand. Order by mid-December for the tree; it prints and ships within days.
A personalized Christmas book is on the way
We're working on a nativity keepsake in the same soft storybook style: the Christmas story told gently for little ones, personalized with your child's name. It isn't ready to order yet, so we're doing this the honest way.
Be first to know when it opens
Leave your email and we'll send one note the moment the Christmas book is ready to order. No charge today, no spam after.
No charge and no spam: one email when the book opens, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
First Christmas questions, answered plainly
What is a good gift for a baby's first Christmas?
Something the family will bring out every December after: a first Christmas book, a dated ornament, or a keepsake with the baby's name on it. The baby won't remember the day; the gift is really for the tradition it starts.
What books are good for a baby's first Christmas?
A sturdy board book telling the nativity story simply, plus one bedtime book they'll grow into. Board books survive being chewed; the nativity story gives the day its meaning from the very first year.
Do babies get anything out of Christmas books?
More than it looks like. Babies latch onto the rhythm of a parent's voice long before the words mean anything, and a book read every December becomes one of the first traditions they recognize.
Should the first Christmas gift be religious?
That's the family's call. If they celebrate the birth of Jesus, a nativity book or a faith keepsake gives the gift a meaning that outlasts the toys. Our free Christmas story is a gentle place to see the tone that works for little ones.
By Hannah Whitford, Childhood Bible Stories · Last updated August 2026
The story at the center of it all costs nothing.
Read our gentle Christmas Bible stories aloud this December, and print the coloring pages for the long afternoons before the big day.